4.4 KiB
I get often asked why do I use Telegram even if it’s known to have bad crypto. The answer is that crypto doesn’t always matter.
Please read why I removed my Telegram account!
The main reason is usernames, I can take one and share it to people for them to contact me instead of giving my phone number to everyone. This also applies to groups where people see only the name and optionally username, not the phone number (like at WhatsApp and possibly Signal).
This makes Telegram somewhat more open version of Slack as anyone can join public groups without being invited by email address, public link or invite link that group creator can get.
Telegram also is cross-platform and welcomes third party clients unlike WhatsApp and Signal (which gives me the impression of being a little more transparent WhatsApp reason). The official clients are open source (but like Android the source code always seems to be released some time after the release) and there are unofficial clients for Sailfish OS and Ubuntu Touch.
And back to the bad crypto, I don’t see what it matters if Telegram can read the messages I send with cloud chat or attacker the secret chat messages if the same groups there are on Facebook where Facebook can read all the messages or the groups are relayed to IRC where most of people sadly connect using plain text connection and send the plaintext around the internet where anyone at correct position could read the messages.
If we compare Telegram to IRC, Telegram immediately has the advatance of being in groups/online receiving messages always since you join the group. With IRC you would disconnect and join all the time when you power off your devices unless you have took the time to learn using shells (terminal multiplexer, CLI IRC client) or bouncers.
It seems like IRC has very little requirements (without shell/bouncer), but Telegram only requires phone number for logging in / registering and you can do that on any client even web.telegram.org and you see the same (not secret chat) messages on all clients. One could argue that SMS verification is insecure, but you can enable two factor authentication from the settings and enable password that you will always be asked for in addition to the SMS/Telegram code.
But what if you need the stronger crypto? If you only communicate with Android/iOS users, Signal might work for you, if you also need to communicate with Windows Phone users, you must probably use WhatsApp where most of your family/friends most likely already are.
Most universal protocol would probably be XMPP and you can use e2e encryption with it either by OTR, OpenPGP or OMEMO where OMEMO is at time of writing only supported by Conversations, (Android-only, free on F-Droid) and Gajim, (cross-platform desktop client).
PS. I encourage using some of the other options instead of having very private/secret dicussions on Telegram as it’s always possible to give your number or XMPP ID and send people to contact you there. If you need XMPP ID, try podupti.me where you will also get a Diaspora* account. (Note that not all pods have XMPP enabled, check the services offered.)
PPS. I am somewhat unhappy with this post as it looks worse than I imagined, but improving pull requests are always welcome.